CMS data processed
  • Compare
  • Watch list

Otterbein SeniorlifeNursing home chain, as named in the CMS provider file

CMS lists 20 certified nursing homes in 2 states under this chain name.

Homes

Nursing homes of Otterbein Seniorlife, in order of state and city
Nursing homeCityStateOverall ratingCitations, latest cycleFinesLast standard survey
Otterbein Franklin Seniorlife Comm Res & Com CareFranklinIN3 of 55$14,18621 Aug 2025
Otterbein Union TownshipBataviaOH4 of 57$7,00815 Jan 2026
Otterbein SpringboroCentervilleOH4 of 59$030 Apr 2026
Otterbein-CridersvilleCridersvilleOH4 of 510$023 Apr 2025
Otterbein MiddletownFranklinOH4 of 59$08 Jan 2026
Otterbein GahannaGahannaOH3 of 516$013 May 2026
Otterbein at GranvilleGranvilleOH5 of 54$028 Apr 2026
Otterbein North ShoreLakesideOH5 of 57$027 Mar 2026
Otterbein Lebanon Retirement CommunityLebanonOH5 of 56$012 Sep 2025
Otterbein LovelandLovelandOH1 of 516$025 Aug 2025
Otterbein at MainevilleMainevilleOH4 of 58$59,4493 Apr 2025
Otterbein MonclovaMonclovaOH2 of 514$47,17127 Mar 2025
Otterbein New AlbanyNew AlbanyOH1 of 511$23,98026 Feb 2026
Otterbein Portage ValleyPembervilleOH4 of 58$018 Jun 2025
Avalon by Otterbein at PerrysburgPerrysburgOH2 of 514$018 Aug 2025
Otterbein St Marys Retirement CommunitySt MarysOH4 of 56$025 Jun 2026
Otterbein Sunset VillageSylvaniaOH3 of 518$024 Oct 2024
Otterbein Tipp CityTipp CityOH3 of 514$03 Apr 2025
Otterbein Sunset HouseToledoOH3 of 58$01 May 2025
Green Hills CenterWest LibertyOH3 of 56$16,80111 Sep 2025

Facilities may see a change in their overall rating for a number of reasons. Since the overall rating is based on three individual domains, a change in any one of the domains can affect the overall rating. Any new data for a nursing home could potentially change a star rating domain.

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Five-Star Quality Rating System: Technical Users' Guide, July 2026. CMS processed the data on . CMS names the chain of each home in its provider file. The file can show a change of chain late.

The chain in figures

A group of nursing homes under one chain name in the CMS provider file.

The homes of Otterbein Seniorlife have 1,344 certified beds. 20% of the homes have a CMS overall rating of 1 or 2 stars. In the nation, the share is 39%. The homes have 44.5 health citations for each 100 certified beds in the last three survey cycles. The figure for the nation is 26.7. CMS lists 9 fines with a total of $168,595 for these homes in its penalties file. 111 of the 551 chains with 3 or more homes in the CMS provider file have more nursing homes. Health citations for each 100 certified beds went from 16.3 in the cycle before to 14.6 in the latest cycle. The figure for the nation went from 9.2 to 8.6 in the same two cycles. The share of for-profit homes differs most from the figure for the nation: 0% in this chain, 74% for the nation.

Otterbein Seniorlife, beside the nation
MeasureOtterbein SeniorlifeUnited States
Median overall rating43
Median health citations of a home, three cycles2623
Health citations for each 100 beds, three cycles44.526.7
Median nurse hours per resident per day4.13.7
Median nurse staff turnover in a year49.1%44.7%
Fines in the CMS penalties file$168,595$445,738,479
Nursing homes of Otterbein Seniorlife by CMS overall rating
Overall ratingHomesShareUS share
5 of 5315%21%
4 of 5735%19%
3 of 5630%20%
2 of 5210%20%
1 of 5210%19%

States

Nursing homes of Otterbein Seniorlife by state, in order of name
StateHomes
Indiana1
Ohio19

F-tags in the chain

The requirements that the citations at these homes name most often.

F-tags with the most citations at the homes of Otterbein Seniorlife, three survey cycles
F-tagRequirement (CMS text)Citations
F0689Ensure that a nursing home area is free from accident hazards and provides adequate supervision to prevent accidents.41
F0812Procure food from sources approved or considered satisfactory and store, prepare, distribute and serve food in accordance with professional standards.41
F0880Provide and implement an infection prevention and control program.39
F0760Ensure that residents are free from significant medication errors.25
F0686Provide appropriate pressure ulcer care and prevent new ulcers from developing.23
F0684Provide appropriate treatment and care according to orders, resident’s preferences and goals.23
F0580Immediately tell the resident, the resident's doctor, and a family member of situations (injury/decline/room, etc.) that affect the resident.18
F0761Ensure drugs and biologicals used in the facility are labeled in accordance with currently accepted professional principles; and all drugs and biologicals must be stored in locked compartments, separately locked, compartments for controlled drugs.15

Fines by year

The CMS penalties file holds about three years. The first year and the last year are not complete.

Fines for the homes of Otterbein Seniorlife by year, from the CMS penalties file
YearPenaltiesFines
20231$47,171
20242$25,625
20255$71,819
20261$23,980

Questions

In which states does Otterbein Seniorlife have nursing homes?
The homes are in Indiana (1) and Ohio (19). The number is the count of homes.
Are homes of Otterbein Seniorlife in the Special Focus Facility program?
CMS lists no home of the chain as a Special Focus Facility or as a candidate.
What changed at the homes of Otterbein Seniorlife in the last CMS update?
The site recorded 31 changes at these homes from the CMS data of 1 Oct 2026.
How does the site decide which homes are in the chain?
The site uses the chain name in the CMS provider file. It adds no home and removes no home. CMS processed the file on 1 Oct 2026.